In short
2-wire video intercoms reuse old intercom wiring; IP intercoms run on network cable with PoE. How each works, the pros and cons, and which suits your home or block.
Choose an IP video intercom when you can run new network cable: each device gets one cable that carries power (PoE) and data, and it connects easily to your network and mobile app. Choose a 2-wire intercom when you are replacing an old intercom and want to reuse its existing two-core wiring instead of rewiring the building. Both can give you HD video, mobile calls and remote unlock.
Key Takeaways
- A 2-wire system sends power, audio, video and control signals over the same pair of wires.
- An IP system uses a network cable to each device, usually powered by a PoE switch.
- For a new installation in a home or office, IP is simpler to expand and to link with CCTV and door access.
- For an older block or house with intercom wiring already in the walls, 2-wire avoids hacking and new trunking.
How does a 2-wire video intercom work?
A 2-wire video intercom is an intercom that sends power, audio, video and control signals over a single pair of wires. Older intercoms, especially in apartment blocks, were built on a pair of copper wires to each unit, and a 2-wire system reuses that pair. Hikvision describes its 2-wire HD range as operating “over the existing copper wire infrastructure within the building”, so an upgrade can be done “with minimal disruption to residents”.
In Singapore, the RiverGate condominium replaced its analogue system with a Hikvision two-wire video intercom covering 545 apartments, each with an indoor station that has a video screen.
How does an IP video intercom work?
An IP video intercom is a network device, like an IP camera. Each outdoor and indoor station has its own network cable back to a switch. PoE (Power over Ethernet) means the same cable also powers the device, so there is no separate power point at the gate or door.
Our Hikvision video intercom packages are PoE powered, and Video Intercom Package 2 includes the PoE switch. Because the stations sit on your network, they connect to the mobile app and can share the network with an IP CCTV system.
2-wire vs IP: which is better?
| 2-wire | IP (PoE) | |
|---|---|---|
| Cabling | Reuses an existing two-core intercom pair | A network cable to each device |
| Power | Over the same two wires, from a central power unit | Over the network cable from a PoE switch |
| Best for | Replacing an old intercom where rewiring is hard | New installations, renovations and offices |
| Expanding later | Limited by the 2-wire system’s design and cable runs | Add a device wherever you can run a network cable |
| Linking with CCTV and access control | Depends on the system | Straightforward on the same network |
When should you keep your old intercom wiring?
Reuse the old wiring when running new cable would mean hacking walls, new trunking across a finished interior or work in common areas you cannot easily touch. That is the typical case in an older condo block, and in a landed house where the gate cable runs underground in a sealed conduit.
Before deciding, check the old cable is sound. Corroded joints or a cable that has been cut and taped several times can cause the same problems on a new system.
When is IP the better choice?
Pick IP when you are renovating, building new, or the cable route is easy, for example an existing empty conduit to the gate. It is also the better choice for offices, where the intercom often needs to work with door access and CCTV. See our video intercom options and prices for the packages.
What to ask before you replace an intercom
- Is there existing intercom wiring, and where does it run?
- Can a network cable be pulled through an existing conduit to the gate or door?
- How many indoor monitors do you need, and on which floors?
- What should the intercom unlock: an auto gate, an electric lock or an EM lock?
- In a condo, does the work touch common property that needs MCST approval?
Get advice on your intercom
Send us photos of your current intercom, the gate or door and the cable route, and we will tell you whether to reuse the wiring or run new cable. Request a quote, contact us or see our intercom and door access packages.
Sources
- Hikvision, “Same old cables. Brand new intercom system.” (20 June 2024): https://www.hikvision.com/en/newsroom/blog/same-old-cables-brand-new-intercom-system/
- SourceSecurity.com, Singapore RiverGate condominium switches analogue system to Hikvision two-wire video intercom: https://www.sourcesecurity.com/news/singapore-rivergate-condominium-switches-analogue-system-hikvision-two-wire-video-intercom-system-co-3425-ga.1584942726.html
Frequently asked questions
- Can a 2-wire intercom send HD video?
- Modern 2-wire systems can. Hikvision’s 2-wire HD range, for example, is designed to carry high-definition video and audio over existing two-core cable.
- Do I need a power point at the gate for an IP intercom?
- Not with PoE. The network cable from the PoE switch powers the outdoor station, so no separate power point is needed at the gate.
- Can I mix 2-wire and IP devices?
- Some systems have gateways that connect the two, but it depends on the brand and model. Ask before buying devices from different ranges.
Want this done for you?
We supply and install CCTV, door access, video intercom and Wi-Fi systems across Singapore, from Hikvision, Uniview, Vstarcam, TP-Link, Ruijie and EZVIZ. Send a photo or floor plan and we will recommend a setup and a fixed price.